ikiwiki/doc/todo/else_parameter_for_map_plugin.mdwn

[[!tag patch done]]

[[plugins/map]] (and I) could benefit from a bonus parameter:

	else="Display this if no page matches the PageSpec"

This was quite simple, so I implemented this (branch "map" in my
ikiwiki repo, see my user page for the up-to-date URL). Not patched the
documentation yet, I'm waiting for feedback first, but I'll do it for sure. -- [[intrigeri]]

> Can't a [[plugins/conditional]] be for this?
> --[[Joey]]

>> Hmmm, what do you mean? Adding a syntax such as the one below?
>> Or something else?

        \[[!if test="map(" then="..." else="..."]]

>> What would you write in the `then` clause?
>> I'm not opposed at all to rewrite my two-liner, but I don't understand.
>> --[[intrigeri]]

	\[[!if  test="foo/*" then="""
	[[!map pages="foo/*"]]
	""" else="no pages"]]

--[[Joey]]

>>> I'm not convinced: the syntax you're proposing implies to duplicate
>>> the pagespec (once in the test clause, and once in the map query), which I find
>>> not only inelegant, which I can live with, but also tiring and unpractical:
>>> my `else` suggestion
>>> finds its roots in map queries with rather long pagespecs. On the other
>>> hand, if I'm the only one using map in such a way, I can live with this
>>> heavy duplicated syntax without bloating the map plugin with features
>>> no-one but me needs. On the other other hand, the patch is a 3-liner.
>>> I'm not fixed yet, I'll think about it. --[[intrigeri]]

>>>> Write a [[plugins/template]] which accepts a pagespec and an
>>>> "else" clause, and then you won't have to duplicate the
>>>> pagespec. --[[JoshTriplett]]

>>>> Yeah, the patch is obviously very simple. My problem with it really is
>>>> that there would seem to be several other places in ikiwiki where
>>>> someone might want to be able to handle an "else" case where a
>>>> pagespec expands to nothing. And adding else cases for all of them
>>>> could be a bit much. --[[Joey]]

>>>>> Agreed, and tagging as done. For the record, here is the [[plugins/template]] I use:

        \[[!if test="<TMPL_VAR raw_pages>"
        then="""<TMPL_VAR intro>
        [[!map pages="<TMPL_VAR raw_pages>"]]"""
        else="<TMPL_VAR else>"]]

>>>>> --[[intrigeri]]